i can has NIGHT THREE?

:V you could ask if zalgo is malicious/replicates/whatever. idk. question asker roles are usually quite limited and thus not all that useful unless there's a big mystery we're trying to solve.

you could ask if anyone (not including Cure*) has faked a quirk. So we'd know if people are pretending to have quirks that they don't actually have. You could narrow it down to D1/D2 if you like. I'm not sure why anyone would do that, and it's not really useful if you get yes from it, but it's something to ask I guess.


*because i was comic sansing for a while and kiyo might troll you by saying yes to that

Yeah, as I suggested at the top of the phase, I'd recommend asking if anyone has claimed to have a quirk that they don't actually have.

Or check if any individual who has a suspicious quirk actually has it. But you need to ask about specific quirks, since you can't ask about specific people.

I must have missed it. :P


I don't see why anyone would fake having a suspicious quirk though? Why draw attention to yourself?


But yeah, vowels you could go with my suggestion of asking about fake quirks if you can't think of anything better by the end of the phase--and I'm sure there's lots of better questions to ask. That one's not particularly useful since there's no real reason for anyone to actually fake a quirk unless they're trying to hide a real quirk under it but... as soon as someone else gets the real quirk it'd be obvious.

Okay, the reason I outed the whole question role what because I thought we could coordinate a strategy of finding the mafia though checking and seeing who was posting a quirk they either didn't actually have, or one they gave to themselves. So if you asked something like:

"Does the Sax Roll quirk come from a role that states it must be given to someone other than the person to whom the role belongs?" and if the answer is "No," then we know the person who posted the sax role is either faking the quirk, or it comes from a role that functions differently from what I think the default Town set-up is. Either way the person who has the quirk has some answering to do.

(I picked Sax roll at random).

P.S. you can only ask yes or no questions.

Hey all, and hey to all the mothers out there for mothers' day.

Re: Question asking
We need to be careful here. This is an Extremely OP ability but is really easy to make vague. I'm a little worried that some of the suggestions on the table will come up with inconclusive results. For example, saying "someone has faked a quirk" is up to interpretation, as Raie points out.

Also I still feel a little weird about the question-outing because having people come up with their own questions in isolation itself can be pretty informative of alignment. I'll be side-eying any obviously vague or unhelpful questions.

In general though, night activity on specific nights should be easy to form questions around, and every bit of info helps. So, if anyone is struggling to come up with a question, please stick to something small so we can still gain info and I don't have to go in and inspect the validity of your question.

Re: Lucasgate
I feel like there were enough votes on Lucas to turn it into an unrecoverable situation, so I'm really interested in what happened. I need to doublecheck the timing of votes, but I think we should dig more into this. If there was a lot of early town buy-in for example, then it's possible Mafia was just sitting around watching and eating popcorn. I don't know, I'll need to think more on this, but I'd like to hear thoughts on this from those of you who voted.

drandahl wrote:Hey all, and hey to all the mothers out there for mothers' day.

Re: Lucasgate
I feel like there were enough votes on Lucas to turn it into an unrecoverable situation, so I'm really interested in what happened. I need to doublecheck the timing of votes, but I think we should dig more into this. If there was a lot of early town buy-in for example, then it's possible Mafia was just sitting around watching and eating popcorn. I don't know, I'll need to think more on this, but I'd like to hear thoughts on this from those of you who voted.

The reason I voted Lucas was we had no other leads. My ability that had a 85% chance of success was not a bus or something that would allow him to know about a bus, so he was lying about that. He made sure Cure remained without any abilities at the same time that she got hit with a stun, effectively nullifying somebody who is traditionally one of the biggest speakers.

I was so sure those were maf aligned actions that it's to the point where I'm not entirely trusting that he isn't a miller role. I feel like a Lucas vote was literally the only solid vote the other day, still.

welp. I missed rollover without getting a vote in last phase gomen ;-; Weekends are not very good for me. I should be around for the rest of the weekday though, so that's good.

Yeah, he was saying stuff I knew to be untrue, or at least very improbably to be true, and the role he claimed sure didn't seem town. I waited to the last moment to see if anyone would try to push the vote another way, but that obviously didn't happen.

interesting. Cure was the NK target last night.

wow way to undermine my authority kiyo.

Ninfia wrote:interesting. Cure was the NK target last night.

Hmm. I think I know how you know. Interesting indeed.
And also kind of a dick move, since Cure hadn't gotten any quirks yet. :(