HELLO I am here!! I'm sorry I haven't been around as much since I've been really stressed about things for the last little while... Like I said, everything is burning for me.
Anyways, so, some thoughts: I would have not wanted to lynch either Ninfia nor Five this phase and would have infinitely preferred to go for either Aeiou or Lucas, but owing to the fact that at least two players have mentioned that they will be afk in the run-up to rollover I would really prefer not to split the votes further than they've already been split, which leads me to consider either Five or Ninfia.
I... have never been mafia with Ninfia so I have no idea what kinds of targets she's more privy to choose than not, and the only game where I've lived long enough for it to matter when she's mafia was Gakuen S1, where... hrm.
I followed Gakuen S1 for a while after I died because Ninfia invoked the powers that be and literally tore out my soul from my body every phase. I'd agree with you drandahl that Ninfia does tend to be more quiet when she's mafia, but my main issue with that is that, uh, she's been drawing a lot of attention to herself (due to her tiebreaking) - a lot more attention to herself than she would as maf, I think? I feel like she wouldn't... do this as mafia because her mafia playstyle (at least from what I gathered from S1) involves a lot of caution and slow play (a lot of her posts in S1 were kind of wishy-washy low key posts with her votes ~blending in~). Especially since how Raie was lowkey fosing her in D1 iirc, I don't know if maf!Ninfia would go out of her way to push lynches like that.
This leaves Five, my dinosaur-visiting pal! Life is tough. I... do not know much about Five, for they are a numerical mystery to me and the only game I've played with them would be Literary Mafia, volume 2 (where they were town, so I have no frame of reference for their mafia behaviour at all). Therefore, I can see the reasoning behind drandahl's vote on her because of the series of increasingly weird NK targets. The issue is that I feel like her speculation has been pretty pro-town so far, but I guess it could be a ruse?
For what it's worth, Angel is usually quiet enough that she almost never is a viable NK target for speculative strength reasons unless she's claimed a power role, so I am... really confused by this choice of NK.
I like your quotes, drandahl! Sorry I'm always so quiet. :( I'm pretty shy outside of mafia games.
WOW WAY TO NINJA ME.
I like how you can't read the TV Guide properly, but that's ok, I can't either apparently
I don't really have a 100% favourite food but maybe this will summon Ninfia (and Blaire)