NINJA'D: Okay, gonna post this THEN read what everyone said, 'cause holy shit this took a while to write. XD
Double post, sorry, but some time has passed since my last post, I want to be sure people will see this, and I figure I best get this out while it's on my mind.
First of all, how silly of me to forget:
Maroon Five wrote:Ace was killed! They were Bohemian Rhapsody by Queen. They were Mafia.
CLICK, CLICK
BOOM, BOOM
Second, hmm, down to seven...will, Nautilus has a headache, and the other heavy spec folk are dead, or the host, so, here goes nothin':
There's something I'm awfully confused about, and only Nautilus can really clear this up. Kiyo was a doctor, you've said. One that, even boosted, apparently couldn't do much for Lux before night's end. Question is, and looking back at the rollover posts right after D1, does it kick in right away? So it's Day action Kiyo uses to protect? Does the person she target get an action in turn, or were Kiyo and Lux just trying to throw off Mafia?
This just occurs to me too, more reason to think Ace was the jailer: he wasn't jailed last night. I long thought jail would be more for Mafia...to protect them from ME, the Town's very own, nightly NK. While jailing me would have made it look like they were trying to protect Ace (in case She-Ra wasn't truthful...as what apparently happened), they didn't jail him either, which arguably would have made as much, if not more sense than jailing Vowels.
That brings me to these lists, of where I'm placing people at the moment, given what we know:
Town
- Tiki The Troll. Before anyone goes, "Well, duh you'd list yourself, that doesn't mean anything," I think there's evidence in my favor. On top of plenty of evidence I've been truthful about my role (She-Ra's confirmation, the multiple kills, no counter claims), my apparent path of carnage has been littered with revealed Mafia bodies. Pending the previously theorized, convoluted plot with switching around Angel's and Ezz's alignment reveals now including Ace in that mix, I think that pretty firmly establishes me as Town.
- She-Ra. Affirmed my role, at least in part, and is the only one who can stop me from bringing hell to the Mafia, or any other poor sod in my way. She's been cooperative since this reveal, and, again, pending tailoring tricks, she let me kill a Mafia last night. And while he could have been tailored, he WAS also on the top of everyone's list, including those who sadly left us last night. On top of that, I think it just makes more sense for it to be a Town role, preventing semi-random kills.
Maybe?
- Aeiou. Suddenly came out last night phase with a very handy, no NK role. She was jailed, so this means Mafia didn't want her using it...or they're trying to make it look that way. Either way, they apparently found it worth the risk to jail her instead of me, taking She-Ra's word I'd not be on the loose. But yeah, this seems to insist they more feared Aeiou than me.
- Nautilus. I actually I've actually been going back and forth on whether to rank her the same as Vowels, but I dunno, something with the Kiyo stuff feels off to me. Nautilus has been very pro Town, with her master list, and how she's been voting. The investigator who has gotten no results thing could be a ploy, as no one wants to off their investigator...but, as Kiyo said earlier this game, these things happen. Hell, I was an investigator in a game Nautilus hosted, and I too got jack all for results, heh.
- Jason Derulo: Well, Blaire is playing very...Blaire. But she did give us pizza info, and her behavior toward Lux last day phase really came across as Town.
Which leaves us...
- Chinomi. She's given her power, a boost to Town, yeah, but...well, I've done the exact same thing as Mafia before. Give a very helpful power to nothing but Town until the end, earning their trust until the final backstab. It's possible there's a hidden downside too, esp. since...well, the pizza from Plottie, a Town, was a boost role, right? And it had a downside, a very up front one in fact And yeah, true, maybe it's just a better boost, or something, but then again, are there really two Town boosting roles? I'm interested to see who here claims getting it the phase, if anyone.
- Rasei. A powerful role to put into the hands of Mafia, as Kiyo said. Very true. Then again, Town has a role with an unlimited supply of kills. So giving them a role copier isn't out of the question, I don't think. There's also the fact they did get a vig kill off, which very well could have been a copy of my power. As for why she wouldn't use it on me over and over, it could be limited (she even claims it is, unable to target the same person twice in a row). She's been very excited, yes, seeing me get my kills off on Mafia...but she's feigned excitement at Maf death as Maf herself before as well.
Well, I have my two, I guess. Largely from process of elimination, really. I'm still most interested in hearing from Nautilus.