I feel like it'd take a really inexperienced mafia to panic and recruit unstrategically. I can't think of a team of six players from our player list who would collectively freak out to the extent that they'd impulse pull the trigger.
Flavor text makes me think it's recruiting and not a turncoat but I'm not sure how much stock we can put into flavor text since half the flavor text is out of context quotes from thread and the other half is silly animu drama mystery. (And I asked alca and she won't confirm what flavor is and isn't relevant. Which maybe implies that flavor that is relevant does exist.)
I do really like that we're discussing this, but I'm also not really sure how to move forward with this discussion. Like, how are we supposed to figure out the recruitment method, and even if we did figure it out, unless it really is a relationship ability, how are we supposed to figure out who maf recruited? I don't think we should completely disregard all reads from N0/D1 because even if anybody could have swapped over it's still only one person and the rest of the reads are still valid (even if we don't know which ones they are.)
Here's my unhelpful two cents.
Flavor text makes me think it's recruiting and not a turncoat but I'm not sure how much stock we can put into flavor text since half the flavor text is out of context quotes from thread and the other half is silly animu drama mystery. (And I asked alca and she won't confirm what flavor is and isn't relevant. Which maybe implies that flavor that is relevant does exist.)
I do really like that we're discussing this, but I'm also not really sure how to move forward with this discussion. Like, how are we supposed to figure out the recruitment method, and even if we did figure it out, unless it really is a relationship ability, how are we supposed to figure out who maf recruited? I don't think we should completely disregard all reads from N0/D1 because even if anybody could have swapped over it's still only one person and the rest of the reads are still valid (even if we don't know which ones they are.)
Here's my unhelpful two cents.
- The Facts:
- N0 -> D1 Rollover
- There are 3x stuns
- There is a jail
- There is a protective role of some kind that prevented Kiyoko from dying N0
- There is some role that leads to a murder story getting posted in rollover, I'm calling this the "fanfiction" role
- kiku, Kotakia, chinomi and deo are not the stun/jails/protects/fanfiction, and did not send the kill.
D1 -> N1 Rollover- There is a recruiter or turncoat role.
- There are 3x stuns
- Hints and claims:
- Kiyoko can only vote no vote or no lynch (according to Kiyoko)
- Kiyoko is not neutral (according to Kiyoko)
- Cure can't initiate confessions (according to Cure)
- Rasei and Sammiya are in a non-romantic sisterly relationship and can send notes to each other (confirmed by both)
- If Kotakia is without a partner for 3 phases, demon gets released (according to Kotakia)
- Kotakia's ability is passive (according to Kotakia)
- T3tsuya does not have a revenge-kill that triggers upon rejection (according to T3tsuya)
- Ezreal: "I can confirm [Cure] was partnerless n0"
- Kiyoko can only vote no vote or no lynch (according to Kiyoko)
- Relationships:
- Confirmed Couples since N0: Luxaria/Alice, eleni/Blaire, high seraph/Kiyoko, nautilus/Ninfia, chinomi/Ezreal
- Did not confess on N0: nautilus, Aistaraina, deo, kiku, Rodea
- Did not receive confession on N0: Aistaraina, Cure, Rasei, deo, kiku, Rodea
- Waiting on confirmation: Kotakia/T3tsuya*
- T3tsuya confessed to Kiyoko on N0 (according to Kiyoko)
- T3tsuya and Tiki are a thing? (according to T3tsuya?)
^Tiki apparently confessed to T3tsuya at some point, but broke it off immediately (according to Tiki) - Kotakia confessed to Tiki and was turned down on N0 (confirmed by both)
- Kotakia confessed to Cure on D1 (according to Kotakia)
- Confirmed Couples since N0: Luxaria/Alice, eleni/Blaire, high seraph/Kiyoko, nautilus/Ninfia, chinomi/Ezreal
Last edited by Kiyoko on Sun Sep 06, 2015 6:58 pm; edited 1 time in total