Cry Wolf
Would you like to react to this message? Create an account in a few clicks or log in to continue.
Cry Wolf

Cry Wolf is a brand new forum focused on the forum version of the deception game Mafia/Werewolves

Video Game UPick is over! Town Wins!
We now have a Discord Server!

You are not connected. Please login or register

Welcome to Katabasis Station, Work Shift 4

+10
Rasei
drandahl
ezzelin
Aeiou
high seraph
Ninfia
Mr. Alice
Kiyoko
Luxaria
Entelechy
14 posters

Go to page : Previous  1 ... 18 ... 32, 33, 34 ... 37 ... 41  Next

Go down  Message [Page 33 of 41]

nautilus

nautilus

THIS IS YOUR CAPTAIN SPEAKING. REPEAT: THIS IS YOUR CAPTAIN SPEAKING.

I saw rollover at Ninfia's apartment while also taking photos of her cat and I will straight up say that we are not splitting the vote today because that ratio is honest to god mislynch and lose level. I am going to destroy my data plan making this post. You're all welcome. I am going to drag this game into the dirt until town wins and I refuse to give up.

Biomonitoring Tag - Lux
Captain's Masterkey - drandahl
Flamethrower - gotten on N2/N3
Reactive Medicines (Protect) - gotten on N0
Radios - gotten on N0/N1/N3
Roleblocker - gotten on N0/N1/N2/N3

**All roles have a chance of being from the cargo hold, which means they were gotten on any night other than N1.

All of these roles are still in play. There are seven players alive, and I will admit it right now that I am the only player right now that does not have a role power. The only role power I have is the one that everyone voted on me to have. I will be cool being Med Bay'd today but honest to god we have to find mafia.

Assuming neither Lux nor drandahl split from their original rooms and got a second role, that still leaves a huge amount of roles that are left in play. Even if drandahl got the master key on N0, did split from his room on N1 (since Armory went off on N1, impossible that drandahl took the flamethrower if so) and then got two other roles, that still leaves at least one role or more unaccounted for, since hypothetically he can only have one a night.

I guess drandahl could be lying about having gotten the captain's masterkey since we don't know for sure he's got it, but we can assume Lux wasn't lying about having the tag in play, at least.

This leaves the radios, the roleblocker, the reactive medicines, and the flamethrower.
None of these roles are Lucas' roles, otherwise it would've been redistributed upon death.

Kiyoko
Rasei
Tiki The Troll
Alcasync

vote: Rasei
med bay vote: Tiki the Troll

Tell me why I shouldn't think you're mafia. You're welcome to FOS me up the wall because I'm no less suspicious on hard evidence than half of the people in that list, but we've been plainly dodging the cargo hold situation for phases now and I'm going to put a stop to us avoiding it there.



Last edited by n☆util☆s on Tue Feb 23, 2016 7:10 pm; edited 1 time in total

Luxaria

Luxaria

n☆util☆s wrote:I am the only player right now that does not have a role power.

What makes you think the other two town don't have role powers?

Kiyoko

Kiyoko
Admin

I asked Duck and apparently one person can get multiple roles so it's possible that there is one super maf out there with like three roles.

For what it's worth, I don't have any roles either since I was cockblocked from the Armory on N0 and have been doing ship tasks since.

I am busy with lit maf stuff right now but I will check in later. I am not against lynching Rasei though since I've had the feeling all game that she was the N0 convert.

http://kiyokon.tumblr.com

nautilus

nautilus

With the exception of the reactive medicines, which I can see town lying about their room movement because of the fact that it's probably the best role right now and the one that mafia would want to take out asap, no one has actually claimed entering any of the rooms that have role powers that are in play. Being untruthful about what rooms you've visited is kind of scummy, even if you are town, since you're deliberately feeding misleading information to the game, especially when determining pairings is vitally important to reduce the field of who could be the convert. The only reason why I can see a town lying is because they got the reactive medicines n0; I can't see town not claiming flamethrower if they received it on N2 or later, since the groupings up until that point unless we were really horrible in how we grouped things discouraged conversion heavily enough that mafia would probably not risk trying to convert Flamethrower Person and having them die a horrible, burned death. Radios are useless in the grand scheme of things and are pretty vanilla, and I can't see mafia placing priority on killing someone with the radio because there's no guarantee of the alignment of the other party when speaking through it, and it's not a Very Powerful Role. If a town player claims radios, it's not as immediately dangerous as a town player claiming medicine.

The ambiguous nature of the remaining 3 roles in that list suggests that the majority of these extra roles comes from mafia. None of these roles are inherently town or help town in any way, unless the roleblocker can block the flamethrower's delayed kill in some weird way, since the galley kind of exploded after Blaire died.

The reason why I don't believe the remaining town have roles in play with the exception of you and possibly drandahl if he is town is because there was a huge push for town to congregate into groups starting on N1, and I feel like the remaining players, should they be town, would not be the kinds of players to stray from a plan (with the exception of maybe Rasei and Tiki) and attempt to play the solo hero.

Given what happened on N2, I doubt any of the remaining town players would do so for fear of conversion because of the thread reaction to the conversion, since peeling away from the groups carries such a risk.

Also I totally fucked up saying that statement but tl;dr I don't have a power. I am literally the most plain individual.

I also feel like if reactive medicines was town, they would protect our established clear (ezz) but clearly that didn't happen so



Last edited by n☆util☆s on Tue Feb 23, 2016 7:31 pm; edited 2 times in total (Reason for editing : I ADDED WORDS)

Rasei

Rasei

Vote: Alpaca

I have no role. On night 0 I was in the cargo hold, and the other three days I been in the med bay. Someone has more then one role out there and it's no me. I am crew. If I'm lynch we will lose the game.

nautilus

nautilus

Literally if we vote anyone in this game except myself and Lux, we have a 3/5 chance of hitting mafia so if anyone doesn't vote this phase I'm going to destroy you1

1 I will press my face up against your screen and be very sad

unvote, vote: alcasync

Rasei

Rasei

Biomonitoring Tag - Lux
   Captain's Masterkey - Dran
   Flamethrower - Not Blaire; gotten either on N1 or N2
   Reactive Medicines (Protect) - Must have gotten it on N0. Most likely it was the person converted on N0. Halfway leaning towards Kiyoko, because she is smart and if I was infected she would be the one I would want on my team, besides Lux. It is not in the hands of Lux, Dran, or Rasei.
   Radios - Any night really
   Roleblocker - Nautilus

Already showed this picture of evil kitty but he doesnt want his picture taken.:



Last edited by Rasei on Tue Feb 23, 2016 7:37 pm; edited 1 time in total

nautilus

nautilus

rasei why would i have the roleblocker

alcasync

alcasync

Given that drandahl and Luxaria's claimed items are both in play, and Blaire, Aeiou, Ninfia and Ezzelin were all town, this means that the only extra items that could have been gotten on N0 were from someone who claimed to be in the cargo hold.

I was the first cargo hold claim, and we've already discussed the cargo hold situation a lot but I was still the first person to claim going there when, if I was lying, I had no way of knowing anyone else was in there.

I didn't leave the Armory on N1 and if I was mafia, then unless drandahl or Kiyoko was also mafia and left, then the ship task wouldn't have succeeded, so I couldn't have gotten an item then.

There's no way to prove that I stuck with the plan on the two nights after that, but I also followed the plans.

Rasei has been buddying Tiki a lot in this past game (such as voting him for the tiebreaker) and to be completely honest, given that both Tiki and Rasei claimed cargo hold late, I think they're both mafia.

vote: Rasei because i'm not going to vote for myself.

med bay vote: Tiki The Troll

Tiki The Troll

Tiki The Troll

Home, so, let's do this, then nom:

Hmm...okay. So, a mislynch today let's the Infected/Mafia win. The new info we got from the server room shows a lot more roles than have been revealed, or even discussed in the game, really, so probably swiped by Mafia throughout? I suppose the Captain's Masterkey does lend some credence to Dran's N0 claim (though I don't think anyone really doubted that). Mostly, what this list tells me is, if Crew nails an Infected, then the game will be a lot more even again, with two new power roles (hopefully) going Crew.

Well...unless we vote out the Flamethrower...heh...

Anyway, I think we're still at more or less the same point we were last voting phase...sans Vowels. I think that leaves the core suspects as:


  1. Tiki the Troll: I was one of the 4 claims for the Cargo Hold. I was also in the room that failed to activate, though we already flushed out an Infected from that, and only one person aside from Lux left the room (that or all of us, and I doubt Vowels was lying , and I now I wasn't). I've been kept on the list though, despite at least attempting spec (or at least to consolidate spec with El Zorro), as I seem to find myself in these odd spots, even after following the plans, once we had some ironed out, heh.
  2. Rasei: Also made a Cargo Hold claim, and botched her wording. We've all been making these little mechanic mistakes during this game though, so it might not mean much.
  3. Drandahl: Alone, like Lux on N0, which is supposedly when he got that key. That has kept him on the suspects list, despite actually being very helpful in consolidating the votes into single posts. However, last phase he threw out that, "keep it exciting vote" during what could have been our last voting phase, which is...well...


Ninja'd by Nautiwall:

Well, then, uh. Okay. Ma'am, yes ma'am, heh. No splitting the votes is good with me.
Vote: Rasei

I admit though, I, myself, feel stronger on Dran, seeing his verbal slip as more damning that Rasei's...though I know that Cargo Hold keeps coming back to haunt you, so, heh. We'll get this over with first (and hopefully not last...).

And sure, Med Bay vote: Tiki The Troll

Edit: More ninjas I missed (bah, I wanna eat!)

Unvote: Rasei

Eating, then coming back once this thread settles down. :P

Kiyoko

Kiyoko
Admin

You're not going to get a long post from me because I'm doing lit maf stuff right now since Raie won't be around for lit maf rollover but

Rasei wrote:Reactive Medicines (Protect) - Must have gotten it on N0. Most likely it was the person converted on N0. Halfway leaning towards Kiyoko, because she is smart and if I was infected she would be the one I would want on my team, besides Lux. It is not in the hands of Lux, Dran, or Rasei.

I was already fairly provably in the Armory on N0, given that Blaire was there, didn't get the flamethrower, and flipped town which means she was telling the truth about someone else being in the armory with her. On that note, I am a little upset on a petty immature child level that someone else got the flamethrower and I didn't but I guess that is kind of really beside the point.

imho

if alca is maf then drandahl is maf and vice versa

if rasei is maf than tiki is maf and vice versa

I'm not going to FoS anyone right now because I'm only half paying attention but I am going to say that if Rasei is maf and she literally gets away with the biggest misspeaks I've ever seen in a mafia game, and we all just kind of overlooked it because "Rasei has always been kind of weird" I am probably going to die laughing

http://kiyokon.tumblr.com

nautilus

nautilus

now that i think about it

no one has really defended rasei this entire game, and if she were mafia i'd figure at least one mafia member would've strongly defended her at this point because she's been fos'd so many times by like 5 different players. she was unanimously thought of as mafia the previous phase.

also my data plan is crying so i'm going to go for now BUT IF I FIND INTERNET BEFORE ROLLOVER TOMORROW IF I'M STILL ALIVE

i will be back

Rasei

Rasei

ARG! I HATE MUMMY TEARS! WHEN HAVE I EVER MADE MUMMY TEARS APPEARED ALCA? WHEN? NAME A TIME WHEN I VOTED FOR TIKI WHEN I DIDN'T HAVE 100% PROOF THAT HE WAS A SLIMEBAG. NAME A TIME WHEN I DIDN'T SORT OF BUDDYING TIKI. I HAVE BARELY TALK TO TIKI THIS GAME. ALSO I WAS DRUNK FOR MOST OF THE PHASE, AND I DON'T EVEN REMEMBER MY REASONING OTHER THAN IT WOULD BE FUNNY TO GIVE HIM THE ROLE.

MED BAY VOTE:RASEI

COME OFF OF IT! I BEEN ASKING FOR IT FOR THREE BEEPING PHASE TO CLEAR MYSELF. IN FACT I'M FINDING IT TO BE A LITTLE STRANGE THAT PEOPLE AREN'T USING IT ON ME. INFECTED DO NOT WANT ME CLEAR SO THEY ARE VOTING FOR THE OTHER LESS SCUMMY PEOPLE.

alcasync

alcasync

I am town. I have followed the plan every phase starting N1, which is the first phase we had a plan. It's very unlikely that I was the N0 convert because I was in the cargo hold with three other people, at least some of which are probably lying, but that's where I was.

On N1, I was in the armory with drandahl and Kiyoko and the task went off. At least one of me/drandahl/Kiyoko has to have been town, because there were only three mafia at the time and high seraph was one of them. If two of me/Kiyoko/drandahl were mafia, whoever was mafia would probably have converted the third one, but no conversion happened that night so it's likely that on N1, two or more of me/Kiyoko/drandahl was town.

On N2 a conversion happened, and there's no way to tell who it was, but I'm not the kind of person who would run off on my own. I guess all you have is my word for it but I would never do something that would disappoint my entire team like that.

On N3 I was with Kiyoko/drandahl/Luxaria and the task went off. I imagine Luxaria stayed in the room and did the ship task which means that at most one person could have gone off, and once again, it wasn't me.

I don't really know what else I can say in my defense but I am not mafia, I have been trying as hard as I can to speculate when I have time even though I've been really busy this month. I honestly don't understand the arguments against me so if somebody actually suspects me and is not just randomly voting in hopes of hitting a 3/5 chance, can they please let me know why? ;v;

I agree that if we split the votes this phase then we'll lose, but please please don't just bandwagon without thinking it through because I am not mafia and if we lynch me just for the sake of everyone voting for the same person, this game will end.

Kiyoko

Kiyoko
Admin

Okay now that I am done with lit maf and can actually sit down to write a post.

I'm not going to bother talking about myself because I've already done the whole "I stuck to the plan" song and dance.

For what it's worth, I don't think alca or Mitsu are the types to go off on their own so I it's unlikely that either of them are the convert in either phase (given the cargo hold excluding them from being n0 convert). I'm going to assume Luxaria is still town. Mitsu's sudden last-phase aggression is a little ??? to me given that I feel like yesterday's night phase was the right time to start freaking out about LYLO if anyone was going to, but I was already expecting an aggressive push from maf early this phase given that it's already the last phase and that may be coloring my interpretation of the situation. (I guess if Mitsu is maf, then her vote for Rasei and immediate switch to alca would mean its likely that the maf trio would be Mitsu/drandahl/Tiki but that's kind of just an aside and not where i want to focus right now)

Fwiw even if Mitsu is maf I'm not interested in lynching her this phase anyway so at least from my perspective I'm looking at:

alca
Rasei
drandahl
Tiki
(with Mitsu as a possibility for maf but not really on the table for me)

I don't really buy the "No one has really been defending x" as a defense at this point in time because no one defended Lucas either--in fact, the only person who defended Lucas was Aeiou who flipped town, which means I feel like mafia is trying to distance themselves from one another.

I have been kind of MIA due to personal issues that most of you already know about, plus lit maf, so I haven't been following thread as closely as I could have, but imo the N0 convert was one of the late cargo hold claims, which means Tiki or Rasei, and the second convert, I have no fucking clue.

I still stand by that I think alca/drandahl and Rasei/Tiki are maf together (with the third in either set being I don't even fucking know don't ask me)

Instead of rushing for a unified vote so early can we like sit down and talk logically about why the fuck we're voting anyone because ADMITTEDLY, I HAVE NOT BEEN FOLLOWING THIS GAME VERY CLOSELY and i have no fucking clue why anyone's voting for anyone tbh

http://kiyokon.tumblr.com

Sponsored content



Back to top  Message [Page 33 of 41]

Go to page : Previous  1 ... 18 ... 32, 33, 34 ... 37 ... 41  Next

Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum