Tiki The Troll wrote:don't jails affect it that way too? that was the impression i got.
anyway, thanks for putting it kindly, nautilus.
there are some things i feel inclined to say, but, i'll leave it out...i really don't wanna affect the game that way, intentionally or otherwise, and everyone is here to have fun. i'd rather minimize how much fun i can ruin.
anyway, it's inevitable anyway. might as well at least do the running gag
vote: tiki the troll
ninja'd: fair on the not shooting
Yes, but you specifically included your own action in the theory, which seems kind of weirdly self-incriminating? :( Still though, it's the absolute weirdness: what are the chances that
both individuals I'm FOSing in one day the same role?
Even if Five is mafia, knew you were town stunner, and claimed your role, it then makes Lucas' claim that Plot's role is absolutely town kind of weird in retrospect since that means Lucas was either bluffing on Plot and cop'd you instead, or mafia has multiple role cops and got a hit on you (it can't have been you being driven, since you admitted that Plot was your intended target). It just... doesn't make a lot of sense, no matter how you slice it, and the chances that both you and Five would claim identical roles is just really suspicious.
In another game, a long time ago, I was town jailer and someone claimed my role in the thread in an attempt to get a lynch off them, and I immediately claimed back.
Like, the worst thing that could happen as town is if a mafia member directly claims the very action that you performed, and yet you seemed almost... complacent about it? You mentioned that hey, maybe there could be four stunners and jailers, even though Five claimed the action - hello, I stunned Plot - you said you did, too. It just... seems weird, because my immediate reaction would be MAFIA, but maybe that's just me.
Also, do we know whether or not mafia members who are unable to use their role actions due to the rule about not voting can still send in the NK?
I would like to know this too!!