Tiki The Troll wrote:Eh, I have time before work. A rundown of the 7 that haven't killed a Mafia, and/or been revived after flipping Town:
Tiki The Troll
Sure, let's start with me. Made a lot of bad press pretty early on with a big post that discussed concerns about two of the clears. Then got frustrated by the lack of communication and responses, kept pressing, didn't look good either. Though I did stop once I got my answers from Ezz and Five. I'd like to think I've made up for it since then, with all the other communication and spec, including: linking all the flavor to the Mafia (and who did what), helping with the Tet lynch, and tipping the balance that led to the Tiny tie and lynch (complete with spec why I thought she could be Maf). I've made claims...but, the only person who could have said anything about those claims was Plotstickers, who didn't make a single post that day, and got lynched. (On that note, I've only been a part of one mislynch, if we assume Gerry is truthful now (oh, and I forgot, I think I voted She-Ra too, who is looking Town).) My messages have hinted at my character, and in the latter half, cycled Rasei's info dump, complete with new notes I added. I got a lot of FoS from Tet, too. Make of all that what you will.
She-Ra
Seems to be the mayor, or someone else high up there. After all, the lynch attempt on her was "illegal," and some NPCs apparently treat her differently. We thought she might be Mafia for that, considering all the allusions to the authority figures being Mafia, including Rasei being a Town opposing candidate, and Ardonye's character saying it goes all the way to the top in her death flavor. However, Tet seemed to really push hard on getting She-Ra shot, so even with him pushing a lynch on a lynchproof, that makes her look good. (Alternatively, he MIGHT have been requesting a shot against her while also providing a protect, which would have wasted a Town gun. This is only speculation though, as there's no evidence of such.) Overall, been kinda aloof/busy this game, it seems.
Crypsis
Adorable noobie. As such, kind of an unknown, but has at least come across as helpful. Backed up Alca when Alca said her role would cause confusion, and defended her against any FoS. On top of that, sent her helpful messages (and items, if I recall), and even protected her from a Night Kill. The only way she would be Mafia, is if she tried to do the same thing with Alca that Tiny did with Ninfia, only with an even bolder strategy, burning an NK directly, instead of just RISKING doing so by giving the item away. Still, with one Mafia already doing such things, that seems unlikely. I don't think her role has been hinted at in any way.
Chinomi
Has soft claimed hard as she could that she sees the alignments of people who act on her. Apparently cleared Deo this way before he died and flipped Town. Potentially a Mafia strat to have her claim something true, then prove she was right, while also having Town burn items on her. At the same time, that could blow up horribly, if everyone were to act on her, she'd have to EVENTUALLY make up a Mafia from the group, which could end badly for her. I don't think she's done much spec otherwise. Was up for a lynch that inevitably fell on Plotstickers...but looking at that vote Tally, the confirmed/dead Town players voted 3 for Plot, 1 for Chi (with Alca voting Blaire), and the dead Maf voted 1 and 1 (with Tiny not voting, Blaire voting Gerry, and Lucas dead).
Five
Been kinda checked out this game, got frustrated when FoS'd, and seems okay with the idea of getting lynched (possibly bussed). Hallmarks of a Mafia Five, who much prefers to play Town, sifting through the clues and speculation to find the truth. However, when Mafia, she tends to play more aggressively, seemingly trying to live up to the forum's perception of her as an aggressive player. That has not been evident this game. Kind of murky as to where she stands. Has not hinted at her role/character.
Mr. Gerbear
Claimed miller, died, flipped Mafia. While a lot of us were convinced Gerry was Mafia, with Alca also claiming miller, and later, strong evidence against Gerry...Tet also pushed hard on that lynch, and evidence since then suggests Gerry has been truthful. If nothing else, he has helped try and piece together the flavor, and puzzle out the narrative of the game so far. Also, the only illicit hints at his flavor upon death were, "Teen with hoodie leaving a store with a Diet Coke," which...sounds a lot like the descriptions of real world young men who were killed under HIGHLY questionable circumstances.
Angelstar
Been in the Blaire camp of, "Oh wait, I forgot she was playing." While fishy, is also fairly typical of Angel, and she has claimed reason to be very, excruciatingly cautious. Was up for a lynch until she finally revealed some info of importance to the thread that makes her character sound like a key Town, at least in terms of the background narrative. This saved her from a lynch, and in doing so, brought the lynch down on Tiny, who flipped Mafia.
Well, that's that. Anything I missed? Anything you guys wanna add?
In part, I anted to do this in case I died...not from Mafia (I'm a decent mislynch candidate after all, and they really need to whittle down the clears if they want a chance), but a Town who thinks I'm fishy, and/or a negligible loss if I'm a dead Town. XD
Edit: Just an inclusion to add I'm trying to re-investigate the most damning evidence against Gerry, and I'll very soon get to see if anything has changed. So, Town with any possible guns, please leave me alive long enough to get that result. Heh.