alcasync wrote:I think that's fair. Out of curiosity, who would you be most willing to vote at this point? I know you mentioned Mr. Alice being high on your suspicions list.
Mr Alice, due to the fact that it is a common (powerful) mafia tactic to silence their weakest conversational member to lead suspicion away from them. Mr Alice is probably the prime target for this and I sincerely don't see a reason Mafia would have silenced her otherwise.
In the infinitely small chance that silencer -was- a town role. It still doesn't make sense to silence Mr Alice, who was not contributing anything of note.
Basically, this silence action reeks. It doesn't make a lot of sense for either party. Which leads me to believe there was the extra intended effect of clearing a Mafia member as the most likely scenario.
And, I hate to say it. But if we're wrong and Mr Alice -is- town. Then the only other solution is that it was a room-targeting effect and Mr Alice was hit randomly. I don't think that would be the case due to the nature of the ability, that being that a quasi-random silence is not actually that useful. You could hit your own buddy by accident if that were the case.
If that were true, that's valuable information to know and if we mislynch due to our current information we at least gain that from it.
So basically I feel like if we're wrong, we at least gain something from it. And given that I also feel we're not in a position to continually NL, this is likely the best and least risky course of action.
That's my 0.02 on it anyway.
eleni wrote:@T3tsuya: hi roomie :'D
Can confirm, we roomed up.
EDIT: I'm likely going to be gone for a few hours to run errands, when I get back I'm going to hope there will be some more discussion. But I'll vote regardless when I return based on what I think the best possible option given our current information is.