i haven't backread yet but here're some thoughts i had in the shower -
regarding my read on aeiou:
- she asked for instructions in thread in the last hour before rollover which i think is uncharacteristic for mafia. i feel like if she was mafia they would have formulated a plan and had her come to thread and immediately put her info down, or just put a vote back onto me & try to sway the vote. she also responded to questions in a way i associate with town aeiou.
- the main thing i find suspect is i'm used to aeiou volunteering night info as soon as she gets votes put on her (to the point that she'll mention her lack of night info, or mention having night info but not knowing what to do with it), so i found it kind of odd for her to withhold important info for so long - it gives the impression of needing time to stall to formulate a story
- anyway i need to backread. if the ratio comes back with a mafia death i'm happy to call her a clear town, though.
regarding aeiou's role:
- the issue with her n0 results claim is that it's just not possible for aeiou to have received eleni in her results if both of them are telling the truth. like no matter how much busdriving you throw in, it doesn't make sense. i'm struggling to figure out a single scenario in which aeiou could have acted on me and gotten results for eleni acting on t3tsuya.
- i do recall that the role priority list got removed from the front page... during d1? it's possible something complex / confusing happened in n0 in such an unexpected way that the hosrs had to amend the rules to make it work. weird multiple redirects in conjunction with weird passives might fit the bill, but i still can't figure out what could've happened.
for the record, if i recall correctly i thiiiink cure has in the past complained about how overpowered watchers are...? is that right... though i think she can't confirm it while she's modding...? anyway if that's the case i guess her putting limitations on a watcher role wouldn't surprise me? i'd like to discuss & exhaust all other scenarios before assuming it's an unreliable role tho
regarding my read on aeiou:
- she asked for instructions in thread in the last hour before rollover which i think is uncharacteristic for mafia. i feel like if she was mafia they would have formulated a plan and had her come to thread and immediately put her info down, or just put a vote back onto me & try to sway the vote. she also responded to questions in a way i associate with town aeiou.
- the main thing i find suspect is i'm used to aeiou volunteering night info as soon as she gets votes put on her (to the point that she'll mention her lack of night info, or mention having night info but not knowing what to do with it), so i found it kind of odd for her to withhold important info for so long - it gives the impression of needing time to stall to formulate a story
- anyway i need to backread. if the ratio comes back with a mafia death i'm happy to call her a clear town, though.
regarding aeiou's role:
- the issue with her n0 results claim is that it's just not possible for aeiou to have received eleni in her results if both of them are telling the truth. like no matter how much busdriving you throw in, it doesn't make sense. i'm struggling to figure out a single scenario in which aeiou could have acted on me and gotten results for eleni acting on t3tsuya.
- i do recall that the role priority list got removed from the front page... during d1? it's possible something complex / confusing happened in n0 in such an unexpected way that the hosrs had to amend the rules to make it work. weird multiple redirects in conjunction with weird passives might fit the bill, but i still can't figure out what could've happened.
for the record, if i recall correctly i thiiiink cure has in the past complained about how overpowered watchers are...? is that right... though i think she can't confirm it while she's modding...? anyway if that's the case i guess her putting limitations on a watcher role wouldn't surprise me? i'd like to discuss & exhaust all other scenarios before assuming it's an unreliable role tho