Cry Wolf
Would you like to react to this message? Create an account in a few clicks or log in to continue.
Cry Wolf

Cry Wolf is a brand new forum focused on the forum version of the deception game Mafia/Werewolves

Video Game UPick is over! Town Wins!
We now have a Discord Server!

You are not connected. Please login or register

Vampires win! COTN

+7
high seraph
Sammiya
drandahl
Rasei
Luxaria
nautilus
Kiyoko
11 posters

Go to page : Previous  1, 2, 3, 4, 5 ... 9 ... 15  Next

Go down  Message [Page 4 of 15]

46Vampires win! COTN - Page 4 Empty Re: Vampires win! COTN Sat Jul 04, 2015 8:51 am

nautilus

nautilus

The forum went down last night so I wasn't around for last night and a lot of things happened when I was gone???

So, going to parrot a few things said so far with this post. Still trying to wrap my head around the different factions here, so please correct me if anything is off:

  1. Vampires now know for sure who the werewolf is. Werewolf is aware they were targeted, but do not know who vampires are unless they target a vampire, according to the response to Kiyoko's question? Surprisingly this means that the werewolf, should their kill be redirected, is one of the few ways that someone can determine vampireness of a person, outside of:

    1. Squatter squats on a vampire's home and sees them leave
    2. Monster hunter


    Completely disregard this if the werewolf's redirected kill happens all the time and not just when targeting vampires.

  2. I agree with the general sentiment in-thread that us humans should leave the werewolf alone, since for the most part the werewolf and the humans have the same general win condition (eliminate vampires) and given the werewolf's current predicament I don't think they'll go SOLO WOLF just yet. Werewolf is also our only (though now severely hampered) vigilante kill in the night phase, and it does us no favors for werewolf to be lynched.

    While the werewolf is inherently-anti vampire, I believe that the mafia will probably leave the werewolf alive for a few phases, because werewolf is forced to kill and their kills have the ability now to deflect away from vampires automatically (aka the redirect away from vampire thing), making them basically the vampire's """vigilante""" with a random target during full moons, since vampires can't act on full moons.

    The silver lining of this werewolf scenario is that none of the human power roles got enthralled, which is pretty good since a vampire mayor or monster hunter would be pretty bad.

  3. @Cthulu: I have a question; probably silly ones but I just want to ensure clarification:
    - Despite being enthralled, can the werewolf convert humans into other unenthralled werewolves during full moons via their redirected kills, or is a redirected kill a guaranteed OHKO?
    - Is there any way, outside of the cold grip of death, that a werewolf can be unenthralled?

  4. Votes: I'm going to hold off on voting right now, though I'm watching all of you. Also I notice you, kouhai!

47Vampires win! COTN - Page 4 Empty Re: Vampires win! COTN Sat Jul 04, 2015 9:21 am

Cthulhuhoop

Cthulhuhoop

I am completely on board with being called Cthulupoops, as long as no one finds it crass or inappropriate.

On a redirect there is still a 5% chance of conversion. Werewolf enthrallment can be partially removed. Night kills on vampires will always be redirected but, the vote change is role specific so that if the lord dies, the werewolf's vote will belong solely to the werewolf.

                                                    The Stakes:

                                               drandahl~ I
                                               Rasei~ I
                                               high seraph~ I


Kiyoko~ nautilus drandahl
alcasync~ Rasei
Rasei~ high seraph



Last edited by Cthuluhoop on Sat Jul 04, 2015 12:51 pm; edited 1 time in total

48Vampires win! COTN - Page 4 Empty Re: Vampires win! COTN Sat Jul 04, 2015 10:50 am

Kiyoko

Kiyoko
Admin

senpai noticed me!

unvote: nautilus
vote: drandahl


Hi drandahl do you know how to react yet or no?

@Kotakia, Are you perhaps suggesting that it's in town's favor to eliminate wolfy? Because if so, I disagree. Even if wolfy can't hit a mafpire, wolfy is still an investivig (with casualties). Since mafpires have no way of killing wolfy between a full moon night and the next day phase, maf has no way to stop wolfy from going, "Hi I targeted X but Y died, so X is a vampire." Additionally, wolfy will probably be going after people that will give us the most information if they die regardless of how they flip, because wolfy wants to scumhunt too. So I see wolfy's full moon kills as nothing but beneficial, although slightly less beneficial than they could have been had wolfy not been enthralled.

To echo Alice's point, all town power roles can claim in self-defense if need be, since we know they're all guaranteed to still be town. (I'm not saying let's all up and out our roles right now, I'm saying that if you're on the chopping block, it's a valid defense.)

http://kiyokon.tumblr.com

49Vampires win! COTN - Page 4 Empty Re: Vampires win! COTN Sat Jul 04, 2015 11:25 am

Kotakia

Kotakia

Kiyoko wrote:@Kotakia, Are you perhaps suggesting that it's in town's favor to eliminate wolfy? Because if so, I disagree. Even if wolfy can't hit a mafpire, wolfy is still an investivig (with casualties). Since mafpires have no way of killing wolfy between a full moon night and the next day phase, maf has no way to stop wolfy from going, "Hi I targeted X but Y died, so X is a vampire." Additionally, wolfy will probably be going after people that will give us the most information if they die regardless of how they flip, because wolfy wants to scumhunt too. So I see wolfy's full moon kills as nothing but beneficial, although slightly less beneficial than they could have been had wolfy not been enthralled.

nah i don't want wolfy down, wolfy deserves to live and win their neutral condition while we win against the vampires. i just don't like the fact they can't strike a vamp now, but it does give us a lynch (if they come forward) the next day if their action gets redirected.

while i don't think wolfy claiming rn is a good idea, it does open up the potential to have a guess about who the mafia are. to enthrall a player they probably had an idea of who would be reasonable to work with based on past experience (if the mafia are vets, if not it might've been a shot in the dark or based on friendships). from there we could probably figure out at least one of the vamps.

http://kotakia.tumblr.com

50Vampires win! COTN - Page 4 Empty Re: Vampires win! COTN Sat Jul 04, 2015 11:37 am

high seraph

high seraph

Ummm im gonna admit im not really in the loop, im reading everything that has been going on ; v; I don't understand why Rasei would vote me off? I think its ok as a strategy to save herself from getting lynched, but it isn't really effective since I'm town... I don't think that's it though, I mean, she was only voted once, its not like we're all gonna bandwagon on it for absolutely no reason.

So yeah Rasei if u could, um, remove your vote, I'd be rly cool lmao

I'll contribute w more thoughts soon

51Vampires win! COTN - Page 4 Empty Re: Vampires win! COTN Sat Jul 04, 2015 11:58 am

Kiyoko

Kiyoko
Admin

Lucaseraph's post ringing some major alarm bells for anyone? On one hand, we're all more or less random voting with infinite vote changes, and Rasei's post even said she was literally rolling a die to determine who to vote, so the freakout is kind of odd. On the other hand, I feel like if Lucas were maf, mafbro would be like "dude chill."

Also Lucas tends to freak out a lot anyway regardless of alignment so /SHRUGS?

Also re: Kotakia's comment about wolf

I'm willing to bet that wolfy is someone who's shown themselves to be a strong player since I imagine maf would want to recruit them. That said, I don't think it necessarily helps us determine who maf is because looking at the roster, we've all played in games recently and so we should all have a good sense of who the strong players are.

Unless you want to go down the route of, "Why didn't mafia target X for enthrallment, X must already be mafia," but I'm not personally gonna go there because there's no way to defend against that and I hate it when people do that to me.

http://kiyokon.tumblr.com

52Vampires win! COTN - Page 4 Empty Re: Vampires win! COTN Sat Jul 04, 2015 2:38 pm

Luxaria

Luxaria

Cthuluhoop wrote:Night kills on vampires will always be redirected but, the vote change is role specific so that if the lord dies, the werewolf's vote will belong solely to the werewolf.

If the vampire lord dies, will rollover text distinguish between vampire and vampire lord, or will it just read as a vampire dying?

I am pleased to hear that the vampires have no control over the redirection of the wolf's vigilante attack. If that were the case, the werewolf is basically a vampire in all but name, even if it wants to discover the vampires in the end.  I also wondered if we could somehow structure our votes to prevent vampire interference, but I guess that's not exactly practical given the nature of mafia as a game.

I do agree with Kotakia that I dislike how we lose the remote chance of killing a vampire on the one night they cannot kill us, thus essentially guaranteeing a town dies every night, but I suppose it might not be a loss because a mafia dying to a vigishot in the night, while helpful, just confirms one player's alignment. But then the lynch trial the following day helps us evaluate allegiances and scumreads. Maybe? Not much point in overthinking something that might not happen, anyway.

Either way, keep being you, wolfy.

Re: Wolfy being a strong player. That is something I thought about a fair bit, because the enthrallment presents a unique chance for mafia to select the player they want to add to the team. Of course, that starts a wifom house of cards where you start to calculate how you evaluate players versus how others and the vampires might evaluate players, and then wondering if mafia would try to dodge investigations by going for less obvious targets and how they weigh that versus the risk of a threatening player ferreting them out if left on town alignment.

But that's just a giant mess, and I agree that there's no way to defend against it, so.

Vote: AliceofOz as the cutest ever because I love you so much <333
Unvote
Vote: No Vote. I'm a bit unsatisfied by the replies to other votes, but it's not like anyone really has much of a defense, so I'm staying neutral since I've never liked random voting. Willing to change to No Lynch if someone's pushing an agenda too hard before rollover in a manner that has me suspicious, or possibly another player if too much scum builds up.

53Vampires win! COTN - Page 4 Empty Re: Vampires win! COTN Sat Jul 04, 2015 2:50 pm

Rasei

Rasei

I was testing out a random vote, High Seraph. I said so when I posted.

I'm going ahead and unvote, then vote:No Lynch for today. Unless someone convince me that we need to lynch someone right this minute.

54Vampires win! COTN - Page 4 Empty Re: Vampires win! COTN Sat Jul 04, 2015 3:46 pm

alcasync

alcasync

unvote

I'll actually be busy today with 4th of July celebrations so I can't really stay long. So I'm unvoting. I'll be back in the evening but not before rollover. Really sorry. ;v;

55Vampires win! COTN - Page 4 Empty Re: Vampires win! COTN Sat Jul 04, 2015 3:57 pm

Sammiya

Sammiya
Admin

Mmmm. I don't think we have enough to go on, either. And, yeah, it's probably best to leave poor Mr. Wolf alone, although the mafia probably will leave them alive as long as possible.

Vote: No vote for now. (Silly fingers, it's not no note.

Sorry, but not feeling well, grklrlk. I threw up earlier and have been cleaning most of the day.

https://crywolf.rpg-board.net

56Vampires win! COTN - Page 4 Empty Re: Vampires win! COTN Sat Jul 04, 2015 4:32 pm

Cthulhuhoop

Cthulhuhoop

I hope you feel better soon Sammiya.

57Vampires win! COTN - Page 4 Empty Re: Vampires win! COTN Sat Jul 04, 2015 5:25 pm

high seraph

high seraph

I wasn't freaking out tho omg... At the time I wasn't very up to date with the game, so I just saw a random vote with no reasoning or anything, and idk how that course of action can be beneficial .-. But thanks for the unvote lmao

I'm gonna vote: No lynch because RN I don't have any leads and there's a party going on here

58Vampires win! COTN - Page 4 Empty Re: Vampires win! COTN Sat Jul 04, 2015 5:47 pm

Kiyoko

Kiyoko
Admin

unvote, vote: no lynch because drandahl probably won't respond as we are celebrating the 4th together, and I won't be active because we are celebrating the 4th together.

http://kiyokon.tumblr.com

59Vampires win! COTN - Page 4 Empty Re: Vampires win! COTN Sat Jul 04, 2015 5:54 pm

Cthulhuhoop

Cthulhuhoop

Have an enjoyable independence day.

60Vampires win! COTN - Page 4 Empty Re: Vampires win! COTN Sat Jul 04, 2015 6:16 pm

nautilus

nautilus

Whoops, sorry about my sporadic activity. I've been working on something for a friend of mine all day and ended up having the day completely fly by.

Some comments:

  • I agree that werewolf shouldn't claim at the moment for risk of revealing their identity and eschewing their win, but I also don't think we should antagonize werewolf because werewolf can help us and I doubt they're going to immediately antagonize the town. I like the portmanteau investivig. I'm going to use that. Investigativig?
  • With respect to high seraph, I can see that he panicked quite a bit to what was a random vote; however, given his pleading posts near the end of TV Tropes mafia I'm willing to ascribe this to just his playstyle. Certainly doesn't warrant a vote of any kind at the moment, though maybe a small look out of the corner of my eye.
  • I also wondered if we could somehow structure our votes to prevent vampire interference, but I guess that's not exactly practical given the nature of mafia as a game.

    Hypothetically we can, if we ensure that there's a two-vote difference between players up for lynch (since the lord can push werewolf's vote onto another play, a two-vote difference means that the lord can only reduce it to a one-vote difference). However, the existence of the mayor (whose vote will always count double unless they're voted on (?), and I'm going to assume these are invisible double-votes, Cthulu) and the fact that we're going to inevitably get split votes (especially with so few people in this game) makes this a bad strategy.
  • Going to go with the flow and vote: no lynch, because no one has died yet and it's basically the same as the start, +roles having acted, and there's nothing really to go on at the moment except for "where wolf? why wolf?" thing we're doing in-thread. Plus I think everyone's going out for parties or is ill (get well soon, Sammiya!) so I don't think there's any point to trying to discuss a lynch now.


All of you are so lucky. I've just been beating Photoshop into a pulp all day :(

Sponsored content



Back to top  Message [Page 4 of 15]

Go to page : Previous  1, 2, 3, 4, 5 ... 9 ... 15  Next

Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum